Utah Legislature 2011: Reloaded | Cover Story | Salt Lake City Weekly

March 16, 2011 News » Cover Story

Utah Legislature 2011: Reloaded 

Utah lawmakers take their best shots at 2011’s big issues.

Pin It
  • Bryan Beach
A tea party-flavored tide helped usher in the most conservative Utah Legislature in decades. The mandate was to fight federal encroachment, offer common sense solutions and ensure transparency in government. Many legislators took that message to heart; others erased it from memory as they do their e-mails in case a snoopy reporter asks for them.

Then with their ducks in a row, these legislators came out guns blazing. They took on the feds, immigrants, bath salts, feral cats and anything that offends the decency of god-fearing, red-blooded, red-state Utahns.

If nothing else, it was a session of boldness. It was a session where “small ball” issues, as former President George Dubya referred to them, were pushed aside in favor of solving big problems in a big way and doing it on a dime.

More bang, less buck.

Immigration Fixes And Tweaks
Too many bees in the beehive don’t have papers, and Utahns demanded the Legislature do something about it. Despite the abundance of tough talk, the Legislature offered more carrot than stick when it came to immigration, deflecting multiple efforts to punish undocumented immigrants.


Top Party Pooper
Rep. John Dougall, R-Highland

Every year, the Legislature pitches a number of feel-good bills that designate days, weeks and months as times of awareness or celebration, be it Italian-American Heritage month (House Bill 44), a month raising awareness of the dangers of outdated medicine (House Bill 241) or Mitochondrial Disease Awareness Week (House Joint Resolution 35). City Weekly discovered an interesting trend in these bills: party-pooper legislators who voted against them. And one legislator who appeared to poop on every party? Rep. John Dougall, R-Highland.

Perhaps Dougall is just taking a principled stand against such bills as time wasters (See “Hot Air,” p. 18). But there were two notable exceptions to his “nay” votes:

He did not vote against Senate Concurrent Resolution 12 to make February “Wear Red Month” to raise awareness of heart disease among women. The voting record shows Dougall was absent for that vote.

And, when it came time to designate Feb. 6 as Ronald Reagan Day, Dougall joined every other legislator in voting affirmatively. Somewhere, the Gipper is smiling on you, Representative.

Rep. Carl Wimmer, R-Herriman, drafted a bill to repeal in-state tuition for the more than 600 students in Utah colleges and universities who are children of undocumented parents. That bill was amended so that the benefit could be allowed if students could prove they or their parents paid income taxes for the previous three years. This compromise bill never saw the light of day, as the Senate kept the bill off the floor and refused to debate it, thus leaving the benefit intact for another year.The Driving Privilege Card

The card created in 2005 to allow undocumented immigrants to purchase car insurance was under attack this session by Sen. Steve Urquhart, R-St. George. He argued the card encourages immigrants to commit identity fraud. Urquhart found himself challenging Sen. Curtis Bramble, R-Provo, who helped originally create the card. After five drafts, a compromise bill was passed. That bill negated the identity-theft concern by requiring immigrants who seek the card to have their photograph and fingerprints taken.

Rep. Bill Wright, R-Holden, was not the first legislator this session to propose a bill meant to bring undocumented immigrants out of the shadows and legally into the Utah workforce. His bill was preceded by that of Sen. Luz Robles, D-Salt Lake City. But ultimately, his House Bill 116 was the one the Legislature decided to run with. An advantage Wright holds—being a salt-of-the-earth dairy farmer—is being personally aware of the economic need for undocumented labor. (It also probably didn’t hurt that he isn’t a Hispanic Democrat from Salt Lake City.)

Wright’s bill would, pending the governor’s signature, seek a federal waiver to set up a state guest-worker program. Applicants would pay a fee to enroll: $1,000 for those immigrants who overstayed on visas and $2,500 for those who entered the country illegally. Similar to Robles’ bill, applicants would also have to complete criminal background checks and be fingerprinted.

One bill that plotted a careful course between states’ rights and the federal government’s right to regulate immigration was a bill crafted by Senate leadership and Attorney General Mark Shurtleff. This bill facilitates federal work visas to be offered by Utah businesses to legal immigrants from the Mexican state of Nuevo León.

Orem Republican Rep. Stephen Sandstrom’s Illegal Immigration Enforcement Act, patterned after a similar controversial Arizona bill, originally mandated that law enforcement verify the immigration status of all lawbreakers. Sandstrom’s enforcement bill survived passage in the Senate only after he removed the language that allowed officers to verify status based on “reasonable suspicion.” Instead, the bill allows law enforcement to check at their discretion the status when crimes committed are class B and C misdemeanors. Serious misdemeanors and felony arrests will still require the officer to check immigration status.

Pin It


More by Eric S. Peterson

Latest in Cover Story

© 2024 Salt Lake City Weekly

Website powered by Foundation