Wrong Side of History
Utahns pay the price of job growth, extraction industries and development.
By Katharine Biele @kathybiele
You've heard the old saying about giving away the farm. That's exactly what Utah's doing with its generous, albeit onerous, tax incentive program. Don't get me wrong. It did help the state weather the recession—but at what cost? The Salt Lake Tribune ran a package of stories questioning why the state keeps its tax-incentive data secret. After all, it just handed Amazon the deal of the century. The company will get a $5.6 million rebate for building a warehouse here, promising 1,500 jobs, but only 130 will be required to pay above county average. In 2012, Think Progress criticized Utah's decision to give Goldman Sachs, one of the country's most profitable companies, some $47.3 million for 1,065 jobs. The Pew Center warns that lawmakers often approve incentives without knowing potential costs, and Utah's hidden data doesn't help. With tax dollars flowing liberally to businesses, it's no wonder there's an initiative to raise taxes for schools.
Extract This!
It must have hit them upside the head when state Treasurer David Damschen scrutinized some pretty nice subsidies to rural counties. And, of course, the subsidies were to help out the state's extractive industries—you know, coal, oil and such. Damschen, a board member of the Seven County Infrastructure Coalition, questioned the legality of using Permanent Community Impact Fund money for these rural projects, and criticized the lack of transparency, The Salt Lake Tribune reported. Indeed, rural Utah is at a disadvantage economically. It hasn't faced the cruel reality of the failing extractive industry. Apparently, neither has the federal government. The Bureau of Land Management is considering allowing drilling in Recapture Canyon, famed for the chest-pounding ATV protest and rich in Native American artifacts.
Down With History
There they go. Four historic structures in what expert Allen Roberts calls Murray's Temple Square. Since 2011, the city has allowed demolition of historic buildings if the project added value to the tax base, the Trib reported. Can you say development? That is the byword of the day. Preservation has always been a hard sell in Utah, where private property rights reign supreme. While Roberts said this wouldn't happen in Salt Lake City, it actually did. Among them were the Salt Lake Temple Annex, the Gardo House and—perhaps most significantly—Louis Sullivan's Dooly Building, demolished in 1964. Utah is rich with history, much of which lies in its architecture. It's too bad not enough people seem to care.
More by Katharine Biele
-
Citizen Revolt: Jan. 17
It's that time of year—Legislature season—so learn from some of the best, and how they overcame obstacles in the political world. Lastly, don't forget the Women's March!
- Jan 16, 2019
-
The New American
A fourth Utah city makes a pledge to have 100 percent renewable energy. Sensationalism adds to #fakenews. Plus, how much to Utah Republicans despise the poor?
- Jan 16, 2019
-
Clear the Filth
Budget problems persist because of misplaced priorities. More on the LDS church's presence at the Capitol. Plus, we just can't seem to get enough polygamy.
- Jan 9, 2019
- More »
Latest in Hits & Misses
Readers also liked…
-
High Anxiety
A new study suggests link between altitude and high teen suicide rates, coal is still king in Utah, for now, and an unhappy former mayor.
- Jul 4, 2018
-
Hot Air, Mind the Gap and A for Effort
It's summer and the livin' is easy.
- Aug 9, 2017
