Poor ol' Phil | Hits & Misses | Salt Lake City | Salt Lake City Weekly
news_hitsmisses1-3.jpg

Poor ol' Phil 

A Lifted Letter & Waterworld

Pin It
Favorite
news_hitsmisses1-1.jpg

Poor Ol' Phil
What is it about the Deseret News and Phil Lyman? Once again on Sunday, the D-News featured the convicted scofflaw on its front page, and said he "doesn't believe" he broke the law. Isn't that rich? If only we could all break laws and simply say, hey, we didn't "think" we did anything wrong. Instead, the paper has chosen to cloak Lyman with a hero's robe, humbled and reading "Hamilton" in his cell next to a drug addict. That was during his "grueling" 10 days in jail for an illegal all-terrain vehicle ride on protected federal lands. There is no comparison between him and Tim DeChristopher, who got two years in prison and a $10,000 fine for faking a bid on 22,000 acres of land destined for energy development. Lyman will have to be happy with three years probation, and a newspaper keeping the myth alive.

news_hitsmisses1-2.jpg

A Lifted Letter
Of course, Utah GOP Chair James Evans didn't return KUTV's calls. Nobody likes to be called a plagiarist—not even Melania Trump. That's because plagiarism is a serious breach of someone else's intellectual property. Just ask Brigham Young University's Joel Campbell, who said, "In my journalism/PR class any student who would do this would fail the assignment and possibly the class." But then you have to know Evans' sense of humor. He obviously wanted to make fun of his counterpart, Democrat Peter Corroon, who was bemoaning the Utah governor's decision to support Donald Trump's presidential bid. As Trump has said: "I was obviously being sarcastic ... but not that sarcastic, to be honest with you." So Evans took Corroon's letter and, ahem, plagiarized it with a Republican bent. Whether you believe Trump will be a disaster or not, KUTV gets kudos for taking the campaign seriously—and for running the letter through a plagiarism checker.

news_hitsmisses1-1.jpg

Waterworld
Here in Utah, water is always an issue. On the other hand, it seems like an issue that doesn't resonate. Recently, there was the Blue Castle ruling to allow a future nuclear facility to use 53,000 acre-feet of Green River water. Now it looks like West Jordan is considering major tax breaks for a Facebook facility that will require 5.3 million gallons of water per day. The Salt Lake Tribune said no community opposition was apparent, while the Deseret News said residents were concerned about costs. But then there's Salt Lake County Mayor Ben McAdams' Facebook post: "This just seems like a colossally bad deal for the taxpayers of West Jordan and Salt Lake County, and we're about to get locked in for 20 years to the tune of $240 million (plus a state tax incentive) and a legal commitment of 4.8 million gallons of water (per day!)"

Pin It
Favorite

More by Katharine Biele

  • Citizen Revolt: Jan. 17

    It's that time of year—Legislature season—so learn from some of the best, and how they overcame obstacles in the political world. Lastly, don't forget the Women's March!
    • Jan 16, 2019
  • The New American

    A fourth Utah city makes a pledge to have 100 percent renewable energy. Sensationalism adds to #fakenews. Plus, how much to Utah Republicans despise the poor?
    • Jan 16, 2019
  • Clear the Filth

    Budget problems persist because of misplaced priorities. More on the LDS church's presence at the Capitol. Plus, we just can't seem to get enough polygamy.
    • Jan 9, 2019
  • More »

Latest in Hits & Misses

  • The New American

    A fourth Utah city makes a pledge to have 100 percent renewable energy. Sensationalism adds to #fakenews. Plus, how much to Utah Republicans despise the poor?
    • Jan 16, 2019
  • Clear the Filth

    Budget problems persist because of misplaced priorities. More on the LDS church's presence at the Capitol. Plus, we just can't seem to get enough polygamy.
    • Jan 9, 2019
  • Cough, Cough, Choke

    Don't forget, air quality will be a perennial story of the year and with the upcoming legislative session, the subject is ramping up again. Plus, keep an eye on what happens to the citizen initiatives.
    • Jan 2, 2019
  • More »

Comments

Subscribe to this thread:

Add a comment

Readers also liked…

  • High Anxiety

    A new study suggests link between altitude and high teen suicide rates, coal is still king in Utah, for now, and an unhappy former mayor.
    • Jul 4, 2018
  • Hot Air, Mind the Gap and A for Effort

    It's summer and the livin' is easy.
    • Aug 9, 2017

© 2019 Salt Lake City Weekly

Website powered by Foundation