Immigration Happens | Letters | Salt Lake City | Salt Lake City Weekly

Immigration Happens 

Pin It
Well, well, we now see the Left and the Right meeting and agreeing.

Jim Catano [“Too Fruitful,” Sept. 30, City Weekly] makes the old Leftist argument about too many people (the enlightened don’t have babies—just the poor and brown people) and the Right just doesn’t like their language, culture and “way of life” threatened by all those brown people. Both points of view are simplistic and wrong.

My question to Mr. Catano: At what point in U.S. history should we have stopped immigration? With the Italians and other southern Europeans? Those are the groups who provoked strict quotas and the requirement to have a visa prior to landing in the USA.

His argument that immigration lets poorer countries off the hook is equally dubious. To date in world history, I can only think of two countries who have not “sent out,” at some point, large numbers of their citizens. Those would be the USA and Australia. I used to think Canada was in that category, too, but didn’t realize that over 2 million French Canadians poured over the border to the Northeast in the late 1800s.

And, does Mr. Catano, although a good Leftist, really believe that a person’s freedom of mobility should be limited? Last I checked, that is a basic human right and one of the first to be suppressed under totalitarian regimes.

My advice is for him to think a bit more about this issue before he decides to limit immigration to his very narrow categories.

Jeff Allred
Salt Lake City

Pin It

Speaking of , City Weekl,

  • Bloomberg’s Place

    Presidential hopeful comes to Utah for a reprieve following Las Vegas debate.
    • Feb 20, 2020

    Nick Passey and The Perpetual Sadness, One Be Lo, Freemind Movement, DJ Mixtermike, Dennis Callaci, Simon Joyner, and more.
    • Feb 19, 2020

    Pioneer Theatre Co.: Once On This Island, Jay Pharoah, The Bachelor Live
    • Feb 19, 2020
  • More »

More by City Weekly Readers

Latest in Letters


Showing 1-1 of 1

Add a comment

Subscribe to this thread:
Showing 1-1 of 1

Add a comment

© 2020 Salt Lake City Weekly

Website powered by Foundation