Furious Debate | Film Reviews | Salt Lake City | Salt Lake City Weekly

Furious Debate 

Two critics go head-to-head over their differing perspectives on the Fast & Furious series

Pin It

Scott Renshaw: As we approach what may or may not be the finale of this particular incarnation of the Fast & Furious series (review not available at press time), I wanted to try to wrap my head around why it's such a big deal to so many people. Because, while vroom-vroom and boom-boom is always going to have a certain hard-core fanbase, I struggle to understand how people think that this series has done those things particularly well.

Danny Bowes: I can't speak for all properly sophisticated cinephiles, obviously, but for me, the appeal begins with the tone, which has the heightened, aggressive and sincere quality of about three shots of tequila. Rob Cohen and John Singleton both instinctively "got" that tone, but Justin Lin embraced its totality and refined it by essentially swallowing the worm. Also, the cast has fantastic chemistry and, to the last, shares the ability to maintain a hair's distance from bursting out laughing at all times.

S.R.: The cast-dynamic thing makes sense to me, and there was an inspired quality to pulling all the characters together so relatively late in the series. My problem has been that, as action movies, I think they've often been terribly made. Lin, in particular, had no idea how to edit an action sequence so that it made a lick of sense. As they got more over the top—"Hey, let's drag a safe around Brazil, or chase a tank!"—these movies were all about fun concepts with nobody in charge who could execute them.

D.B.: This is where I struggle to say anything other than, "I disagree," and where in so struggling, I say stuff like, "the way Lin constructs action sequences may not make perfect linear or geographic sense, but it makes total emotional sense," and point back to the sublime sequence in Tokyo Drift where Lucas Black has at long last learned how to drift, and he and the rest of Sung Kang's gang drift down the mountain. That sequence is the Rosetta Stone for the entire series in terms of both the previously mentioned tone and the way that the whole of a given action sequence in these movies may be more than the sum of its component parts.

S.R.: I'd need to do some research to see whether this is the first time ever that the word "sublime" has been used with regard to this series. I certainly recognize that it's filling a gap in contemporary movie-making—the souped-up action franchise built more on practical effects/stunts than CGI—that only the occasional James Bond film otherwise occupies. I've just longed to see a more gifted action director actually try to click those pieces in place.

D.B.: Then, I guess this is a referendum on Justin Lin, in which case I'm the anti-Sabermetrics old person touting his intangibles ("I don't care what his Wins Above Replacement Director are, all I know is he swings from his ankles and hits those car chases outta the park!"). Also, I'm glad that this is coming into focus, because "I don't get why people like the Fast & Furious movies" is actually answered by "I don't think Justin Lin directs action well," because while the action isn't the whole appeal, it's inextricably connected to the remainder of the whole. The adrenaline inebriation pervades all aspects of these movies.

S.R.: Forgive me if I've suggested this is all about my issues with Lin, since I bow to no one in my disdain for le cinema du Rob Cohen [director of the original Fast and the Furious]. Lacking a connection with the intangibles you see, I'm left with two possible ways into these movies: their effectiveness as old-school action moviemaking (which I contend is minimal) and the unique appeal of this multicultural makeshift family. And maybe the latter would work better for me if they didn't keep hammering the word "family" (though I have a sneaking suspicion it's gonna get a little dusty in theaters at the end of Furious 7 as a result of real-world events).

D.B.: As someone for whom the word "family" conjures images of lawyers, passive aggression and wordless decades-long feuds over literally nothing, I actually like how corny and heavy-handed the "family" thing is in the F&F movies. It's of a piece with every other element. They're big, loud movies that regard subtlety as a forgotten successor to the Model T. Obviously, their appeal isn't universal (just their studio), and shouldn't have to be. But those of us onboard the proverbial 12,000-horsepower Dodge Charger driving through the top floor of the figurative office building can attest: It may be an acquired taste, but once acquired, it's one you'll never let go of.


Furious 7
Rated PG-13 · 137 minutes · 2015
Staff Rating:
Official Site: www.furious7.com
Director: James Wan
Producer: Neal Moritz, Vin Diesel, Michael Fottrell, Samantha Vincent, Amanda Lewis and Chris Morgan
Cast: Vin Diesel, Paul Walker, Dwayne Johnson, Michelle Rodriguez, Tyrese Gibson, Chris "Ludacris" Bridges, Jordana Brewster, Djimon Hounsou, Tony Jaa, Ronda Rousey, Nathalie Emmanuel, Kurt Russell, Jason Statham, Sung Kang, Elsa Pataky, Lucas Black and Gal Gadot
Pin It

Now Playing

Furious 7 is not showing in any theaters in the area.


More by Scott Renshaw

More by Danny Bowes

Latest in Film Reviews

  • Refined Crude

    Booksmart makes raunchy female coming-of-age into an actual movie.
    • May 22, 2019
  • Out in Africa

    Rafiki explores a lesbian coming-of-age in a place where being gay is a crime.
    • May 15, 2019
  • Hobbit Forming

    A literary origin gets particularly literal in Tolkien.
    • May 8, 2019
  • More »


Subscribe to this thread:

Add a comment

What others are saying (6)

Connect Savannah Review: Furious 7 Let’s marvel at how much mileage the studio has gotten out of what’s basically 1950s-style “B” programmers supercharged for contemporary audiences. by Matt Brunson 03/31/2015
Inlander Furious Debate Two critics go head-to-head over their differing perspectives on the Fast & Furious series by Scott Renshaw and Danny Bowes 04/01/2015
Boise Weekly Furious 7 Dominates Competition...Again "Studios are not afraid to place a strong movie in unconventional times and it's paying off quite well." by GlobalPost 04/12/2015
3 more reviews...
Charleston City Paper Furious 7 delivers yet again on adrenaline-pumping action Furious 7 begins, as it should, with a street race. by Dan Hudak 04/08/2015
The Coast Halifax Review: Furious 7 Definitely not boring by Tara Thorne 04/09/2015
Seven Days Furious 7 by Margot Harrison 04/08/2015

Readers also liked…

  • Old Friends

    Logan's Syndrome finds a filmmaker discovering a fascinating story in his own childhood neighborhood.
    • Mar 14, 2018
  • Look for the Helpers

    Won't You Be My Neighbor? and the simple heroism of Fred Rogers.
    • Jun 20, 2018

© 2019 Salt Lake City Weekly

Website powered by Foundation