Cinema | Now a Motion Picture IV: If it’s Labor Day weekend, it must be time for book-to-movie previews. | Film Reviews | Salt Lake City | Salt Lake City Weekly

Cinema | Now a Motion Picture IV: If it’s Labor Day weekend, it must be time for book-to-movie previews. 

Pin It
The first nip of fall may not have hit the air, but literary-adaptation season is right around the corner. And while their number includes both best sellers (Twilight) and Oprah-approved prize winners (The Road), here’s a glance at some of 2008’s lesser-known book-to-movie translations. Release dates, as always, are subject to change.

Source material: Miracle at St. Anna by James McBride

Book overview: In 1944 Tuscany, four soldiers from the U.S. Army’s all-“colored” 92nd Infantry find themselves trapped behind German lines in a small town when one of them attempts to rescue an orphaned Italian boy. McBride skillfully avoids wartime clichés, capturing the unique psychology of black soldiers in a segregated era. His precise characterizations of both the soldiers and the Italian peasants make the story feel like a magnificently specific slice of history rather than something with a grandiose agenda.

Book grade: A-

Reason for adaptation optimism: McBride himself is adapting the screenplay.

Reason for adaptation concern: Director Spike Lee may be passionate about the material, but he’s been known to crank up the Significance.

Film scheduled release date: Sept. 26

The movie pitch:Saving Private Ryan meets Glory.”

Source material: Nick & Norah’s Infinite Playlist by Rachel Cohn & David Levithan.

Book overview: When a recently dumped musician’s ex walks into a nightclub, he impulsively asks the nearest woman to pose as his girlfriend, launching an epic all-night “first date” through Manhattan. The co-authors alternate chapters from the point of view of their two protagonists, lending a wonderful multi-lensed perspective on burgeoning romance. The hipster milieu might be a bit grating, and Norah’s self-loathing a little protracted, but ultimately it’s smart and thoroughly engaging.

Book grade: B+

Reason for adaptation optimism: Long-awaited follow-up from director Peter Sollett (the terrific Raising Victor Vargas); Superbad’s Michael Cera is perfectly cast as the sensitive Nick.

Reason for adaptation concern: Will the book’s hyper-verbal internal monologues translate to cinema?

Film scheduled release date: Oct. 3

The movie pitch: Before Sunrise meets High Fidelity.”

Source material: The City of Ember by Jeanne DuPrau

Book overview: In a dying city surrounded by darkness and facing supply shortages, two 12-year-olds search for a way to save the citizens from impending doom. An unfortunate prologue gives away too much before the mystery has even begun, giving this kid-lit tale a certain inevitability. But DuPrau’s world is well thought out, serving as both a metaphor for humanity’s worst impulses in crisis and as a simple, effective adventure in its own right.

Book grade: B

Reason for adaptation optimism: Director Gil Kenan helmed the smart, under-appreciated kid-pic Monster House.

Reason for adaptation concern: The book’s cliffhanger ending—setting up a sequel—may prove difficult to translate in a satisfying way.

Film scheduled release date: Oct. 10

The movie pitch:The Golden Compass meets The Village.”

Source material: Body of Lies by David Ignatius

Book overview: A CIA agent, desperate to infiltrate a terrorist network, creates an elaborate fiction to force his target into the open. Ignatius clearly has a grasp of his milieu, but this is one of those plot machines where attempts at creating “context” for the main character—an ice-queen wife, a humanitarian girlfriend—all fall flat. Engaging enough as beach reading assuming you’re not looking for any political (or human) insight.

Book grade: B-

Reason for adaptation optimism: Director Ridley Scott + Russell Crowe resulted in Gladiator.

Reason for adaptation concern: Director Ridley Scott + Russell Crowe also resulted in A Good Year.

Film scheduled release date: Oct. 10

The movie pitch:Syriana meets The Kingdom.”

Source material: Marley & Me, by John Grogan

Book overview: Journalist and newspaper columnist Grogan’s memoir recounts life as a newlywed and young father with a lovable, energetic, endlessly destructive Labrador retriever. Marley instantly becomes a wonderfully complex character in Grogan’s hands, in exploits simultaneously hilarious and cringe-inducing. It won’t just be the dog lovers whose pets were their “firstborn” left blinking back tears.

Book grade: B+

Reason for adaptation optimism: Director David Frankel did fine book-to-crowd pleaser work with The Devil Wears Prada.

Reason for adaptation concern: It’s going to require a lot of tinkering to impose a narrative shape on Grogan’s episodic tale.

Film scheduled release date: Dec. 25

The movie pitch:Turner & Hooch meets Brian’s Song.”

Pin It


More by Scott Renshaw

  • Rebel, Rebel

    Two new features show what America's protest spirit is really all about
    • Jul 1, 2020
  • Room Service

    A locked-down hotel provides fodder for the virtual theater of The Open Syrup
    • Jul 1, 2020
  • Movie Reviews: New Releases for June 26

    Eurovision Song Contest, My Spy, Irresistible and more
    • Jun 25, 2020
  • More »

Latest in Film Reviews

  • Rebel, Rebel

    Two new features show what America's protest spirit is really all about
    • Jul 1, 2020
  • In the Bubble

    Jon Stewart's Irresistible falls flat as "both sides" political satire.
    • Jun 24, 2020
  • Epic Catch-Up

    A long pandemic offers a chance to finally watch some of cinema's great longer films.
    • Jun 17, 2020
  • More »


Subscribe to this thread:

Add a comment

Readers also liked…

  • A Dream Come True

    After half a lifetime, Savannah Ostler's Twice the Dream becomes reality.
    • Apr 17, 2019

© 2020 Salt Lake City Weekly

Website powered by Foundation