Brainy Blues | The Straight Dope | Salt Lake City | Salt Lake City Weekly

Brainy Blues 

Can intelligence cause depression?

Pin It
Favorite
click to enlarge SLUG SIGNORINO
  • Slug Signorino

I consider myself a smart person, but why are smart people so negative? We constantly ask, "What's the point? Why are we here?"—questions with pretty depressing answers, if you ask me. The average joe doesn't feel bad about much—he just thinks, "Thank God it's Friday! And thank God for bacon!" Can intelligence cause depression? Nietzsche was obviously a brilliant but bitter person, and we can also include Mozart, Newton, Tesla, etc., as guys who didn't lead very pleasant lives, despite their intelligence. Surely, this isn't all a coincidence? —Marcos San Juan, Madrid

You're being too negative, Marcos. Much as the dim might prefer to believe otherwise, research has generally suggested that intelligence correlates, if only mildly, with greater happiness; the tortured-genius meme is without statistical foundation.

Almost.

Historically, evidence for this alleged phenomenon has been overwhelmingly anecdotal, cemented in the popular consciousness by a steady stream of Oscar-bait biopics. Thanks to A Beautiful Mind, it's easy to picture the schizophrenic John Nash arguing with his nonexistent roommate; if The Imitation Game is anything to go by, Alan Turing was depressed well before he had extremely good reason to be (read: involuntary chemical castration).

With these outsize examples on display, it's perhaps understandable that many people wondering why they're so unhappy will conclude: Because I'm so goddamned smart, that's why. The most brilliant among us, it's regularly suggested, are uniquely doomed to comprehend the limitless expanse of the universe, and, as a result, to confront our own inconsequential place within it. This has loosely been termed existential depression, and is supposed to be especially bad among bright kids, whose advocates may propose they need a regimen of "prescribed hugs."

I'm certainly not cranky enough to come out against hugging children. Empirically speaking, though, there isn't much here. Research over the past 50 years has demonstrated no positive link between intelligence and being depressed or schizophrenic, and has often suggested the reverse. A 1998 collection of surveys from 11 countries found educational attainment and intelligence correlated with marginally happier populations. A 1956 study of former U.S. soldiers found no relationship between scores on intelligence tests at induction and later psychiatric health. Danish research from 2011 found that both depressed and bipolar patients had, before the onset of their illness, slightly lower-than-average IQ scores than the healthy control population. Other research has suggested that kids' intelligence isn't a particularly strong predictive factor when it comes to adolescent depression at least: more meaningful, statistically, are family history of affective illness, experience of parental loss, and, worryingly, simply being a girl. (Does this result from a growing awareness of oppressive social constructs? Despondence over the inability to pee standing up? More research is clearly needed.)

If there's a blip on the radar, it's bipolar disorder. Shrinks have suspected a connection between IQ and bipolarity for some time, but the data haven't really been there. In 2005, though, a Finnish study reported that high math scores on IQ tests in early adulthood correlated with later diagnosis as bipolar, and a recent large-scale study of Swedish records found that kids with excellent high-school grades were much more likely to be diagnosed as bipolar in adulthood.

There's also the supposed link between creativity and craziness. Intuitively, this one seems believable: The story of Van Gogh cutting off his ear to give to a prostitute was my own teenage standard for the ultimate tortured-artist response to girl trouble. Evidence has since surfaced, though, suggesting Van Gogh might actually have lost the ear in a fight with his sword-wielding pal Paul Gauguin, whom he may have been a little too into. Romance or bromance, love's a bitch.

Studies of creativity and mental health haven't been terribly consistent, which is possibly unsurprising given how inherently difficult the trait is to define. In 2011, for instance, a group of Swedish researchers reported that patients with schizophrenia or bipolar disorder (as well as their healthy siblings) were overrepresented among people with creative jobs. But a later study by the same group, using a much larger data set, found that those in creative professions, with one exception, weren't particularly likely to suffer from psychiatric illness.

The exception? Writers. The Swedish group found that being an author was associated with increased likelihood of depression, anxiety, schizophrenia, bipolarity, substance abuse and suicide. Earlier studies had drawn similar conclusions, but relied on very small sample sizes and lots of self-reporting. Those with high academic scores in Swedish and music classes were deemed particularly at risk—which, to the researchers, supported ongoing suspicions linking bipolarity and creativity.

So, to my fellow writers, and I suppose to all those creative-minded Swedes out there, all I can say is: Keep it together as best you can, and we'll hold out for further data.

Send questions to Cecil via StraightDope.com or write him c/o Chicago Reader, 350 N. Orleans, Chicago, IL 60654.

Pin It
Favorite

More by Cecil Adams

Latest in The Straight Dope

Comments

Subscribe to this thread:

Add a comment

‚Äč

Readers also liked…

  • Costly Care

    If everything else is more expensive in Europe, why do we pay more for health care?
    • Apr 19, 2017
  • Burning Questions with Clarence Thomas

    Nine q's Supreme Court Justice Thomas is dying to ask after a decade of silence.
    • Mar 2, 2016

© 2017 Salt Lake City Weekly

Website powered by Foundation