It’s nice to be reminded that Johnny Depp actually can still do good work as an actor, and that he’s not just a walking delivery system for makeup and questionable facial hair. He’s one of the best things about director Scott Cooper’s dramatization of the true story of James “Whitey” Bulger, the brutal South Boston crime boss who was protected in the 1970s and ’80s by his status as an FBI informant—and an FBI handler, John Connolly (Joel Edgerton), who was a childhood pal of Bulger’s. As a procedural, it’s fairly bland stuff, attempting to evoke sprawling Scorsesean gangster tales like
GoodFellas and
The Departed but rarely latching on to its potentially unique perspective on neighborhood loyalties superseding all other obligations. Most of the time,
Black Mass feels far more fascinated with its situation than with the people in that situation. It’s left to Depp to carry things, and he’s a convincingly creepy portrait of hair-trigger violence, perhaps even scarier when the mere possibility of his wrath is invoked. Here’s hoping he can apply this renewed vitality to a story that does it justice.
By
Scott Renshaw