It's been several months since Salt Lake City unveiled, then quickly backed-away from an anti-panhandling ordinance. It's not dead yet, but hasn't been voted on by the City Council either. Homeless advocates say the city has started a crackdown on panhandling anyway. At least some of the acrimony results from the city and the Downtown Alliance making or repeating claims that many panhandlers aren't genuinely homeless.---
Share |
That claim is a part of their pitch to residents and visitors to end panhandling by boycotting the beggars. Don't give change to the downtrodden guy on the street, the pitch goes, instead give it to a homeless service agency or shelter. Telling folks that panhandlers may be faking or exaggerating their destitution in order to get change, however, deserves careful study.
An informal study by local homeless advocates finds that claim is simply wrong.
I'm blogging here to tell/remind you that City Weekly's own investigation of that claim months ago came to the same conclusion, that panhandlers in Salt Lake City are overwhelmingly homeless. You're shocked, I'm sure. Some of you maybe are shocked, though, since when I tell this story I undoubtedly get somebody telling me about some hidden-camera crap they saw on Dateline, or some other hidden-camera obsessed TV news magazine, in which a panhandler drives away in a Bentley.
I don't doubt there are those strange cases, OK? There is literally always an outlier if only you widen the scope of your study far enough. However, talked to individuals who were either homeless, panhandlers, both, or a mayor, and feel reasonably assured that any panhandlers driving Bentleys are just that: an outlier.
I surveyed 13 people--one of them was Mayor Ralph Becker, who happened to be eating lunch in Pioneer Park. Here were the results:
Caveat: this was a self-report survey, meaning I took the respondents at their word. If they said they had a mental health issue, I believed them. Are these people lying to me then driving off in their Bentley's? Perhaps. But I also have homeless friends (don't you?) who helped guide the study and have every interest in revealing fakers. Truly homeless people would love to "out" the homeless guy in a Bentley--many would be even angrier at him than you or I--he just doesn't seem to exist.
Also note that some of these people's living situations have changed since October. Lorraine Levi and Siupelimani "Tiny" Muti, for examples, have found subsidized housing.
Here is the Crossroads Urban Center study,%uFFFDCriminalization%uFFFDor job creation%uFFFD(pdf).
My basic data, collected in October 2009:
Homeless Catalog | |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Name | Homeless? | Shelter? | Panhandle? | Employed? | Mental disability? | Physical disability? |
Lorraine Levi | yes | yes | no | trying | no | yes |
Shawna Govero |
yes |
no | no | trying | no | yes |
Siupelimani "Tiny" Muti | yes | yes | rarely | trying | yes | yes |
Christopher Boyce | "no"/yes | no | yes | yes | no | no |
Moon "Frodo" | "no"/yes | no | yes | yes | no | no |
Peter Uckerman | yes | yes | rarely | no | yes | yes |
Garry McDonald | yes | no | tried it | no | ? | yes |
Kerry Thorstead | yes | no | yes | no | yes | yes |
Vanessa Cowan | as of June, no | no | yes | no | yes | yes |
Rafeal Cardenas-Hernandez | yes | yes | no | yes | no | no |
Carlos Fernandez | yes | yes | no | yes | no | no |
Pierrot de Souza | yes | yes | no | yes | no | no |
Ralph Becker | no | no | no | yes | no | no |