Yewell’s Log 

Yewell’s Quarter Column On Virtuous Politicians, Poor News Judgment and Credibility Called Into Question

Is it time to give up on honesty in politics? Call me Pollyanna, but I think not, and I’m going out on a limb and say James Evans will prove it.


The District 1 Senator-elect’s victory in the last election was tainted, some believe, by a last-minute hit-piece mailing that included a newspaper clipping of a story from a right-of-the-right advocacy tabloid. The article took a dubious shot at Nisa Sisneros, Evans’ opponent in the traditionally Democratic district, over her role in a health clinic’s decision to remain in the district.


With the article was a note from one Howard Dickson, who wrote: “This has made me so mad, I had to send it to you. Because of this, I won’t be voting straight party Democrat this time.”


The only problem, as previously pointed out by Paul Rolly, is that no one can find this Howard Dickson. Inquiring minds suspect someone affiliated with the tabloid, in the Republican Party or in Evans’ campaign (or Evans himself) invented Dickson and prepped the mailing with the goal of scuttling the Sisneros candidacy.


I bumped into Evans at the Main Street Plaza hearing Dec. 10 and asked him about it. Evans disavowed any prior knowledge of the mailing. After accusing the media of inadequately covering the sins of his opponent, he finally admitted to a passing interest in who might have handed him the election with this favor.


I suggested he dispel suspicion of his involvement by clearing the air with his own investigation. Evans is better situated to root out the conspirators than anyone. Hell, it might only take a single phone call. Strike a blow for integrity, I suggested. And quickly.


I’m holding my breath out here on this limb.


• Once he stood outside the parapets and inveighed against the “mainstream” media whores, calling them to account for their toadying to the almighty dollar. As the alternative newsweekly editor he once was, current Tribune reporter Glen Warchol (for whom I wrote one story 12 years ago at the Twin Cities Reader) might have cried “Shill!” over the story that appeared under his byline (“Emerging Wine Advertisements in Utah Are Low-Key”) Dec. 9.


The subject was a wine ad in the newspaper that employs him—the first in the state, claimed Warchol, since the ban on wine and beer ads was struck down last year.


Forget that there have been plenty of liquor, wine and beer ads in print and on the airwaves in that time (perhaps Warchol no longer reads the alternative press). Although the story stopped short of giving the page number of the ad, it did quote the buyer swooning over its effectiveness, leaving the impression that the Tribune used its editorial department to chum for more of the same.


• Two-newspaper towns are disappearing from the landscape faster than elected Democrats. Residents of the Salt Lake Valley can be grateful they still have two, especially the Deseret News. The LDS mouthpiece harkens back to a golden age in America’s newspaper history when editors were not shy about mixing news and commentary.


Take for example a story that appeared on Dec. 14, which reported on the legal opinion by city attorney Ed Rutan, in which he supported Mayor Rocky Anderson’s position that the Salt Lake City Council does not have the authority to unilaterally give up the public-access easement through the Main Street Plaza. The council had previously solicited the opinion of University of Utah law professor John Martinez, who had supported the all-LDS city council in its barely disguised desire to give the easement to the church. In its story, the Deseret News made a point of questioning Rutan’s credibility.


“Since Anderson is essentially Rutan’s boss,” the News wrote, “and given that Anderson disagreed with the Martinez opinion, [City Council chairman Dave] Buhler said he figured Rutan would agree with the mayor.”


There was no similar dismissal of Martinez’s opinion on the grounds that he had been hired by the city council.

Pin It
Favorite

About The Author

John Yewell

More by John Yewell

  • Greased Palms

    The songwriting career of Sen. Orrin Hatch will not likely land him a spot on American Idol anytime soon. But that’s OK, because demand for his CDs is growing—at least among lobbyists with whom he has done business.On Aug. 15, The Wall Street...
    • Jun 11, 2007
  • It’s a White Thing

    There were two industries in the small Southern California town I grew up in: oil and citrus. In those days, the “Mexicans,” as all Hispanics were called, picked fruit. They moved through the trees in the heat, covered in heavy clothing to...
    • Jun 11, 2007
  • The Sin of Hubris

    News item: Lobbyists spent $85,000 entertaining legislators in 2002. News item: Legislators draft laws in secret to avoid input from constituents. News item: Republican leaders rebuke party members for endorsing Democrats.Welcome to the one-party state.Lawmakers...
    • Jun 11, 2007
  • More »

Latest in News & Columns

  • Shar Lewis of Utah Commission on Volunteers

    Shar Lewis, the executive director of Utah Commission on Volunteers, has helped craft the Lieutenant Governor's Conference on Service, April 8-10 at the Hilton Salt Lake City Center (Volunteers.Utah.gov). Lt. Gov. Greg Bell and Sen. Orrin Hatch, R-Utah, will speak, in addition to numerous breakout sessions and a service project on the final day.
    • Mar 31, 2010
  • Rant Control | Sunshine and Lollipops

    Maybe it was the sound scolding Rant Control administered last week—or, more likely, the spate of unseasonably glorious weather we had around Groundhog Day—but recently, the comments on CityWeekly.net have been more constructive and less rude than usual. nKatharine Biele’s cover story about the impact of a planned Rocky Mountain Power substation on a University neighborhood (&ldq...
    • Feb 3, 2009
  • Staffbox | Port 'O Call Memories

    City Weekly’s first downtown office was in the Shubrick building, along with Port O’ Call. Now that she’s gone, what’s your favorite Port memory? n nVictor Serrano: My last and only Port memory was City Weekly’s 2006 Christmas Party! It was a blast! nJamie Gadette: Pretty much every City Weekly function, especially the Wells Fargo bomb-threat cocktail hour. nNick Clar...
    • Feb 3, 2009
  • More »

Comments

Subscribe to this thread:

Add a comment

© 2014 Salt Lake City Weekly

Website powered by Foundation