A sequel to a film as unsettling as
Sinister was almost bound to be disappointing--either too tame by comparison, or too nasty.
Sinister 2, as it turns out, is both. Returning writers Scott Derrickson and C. Robert Cargill continue their story with the still-nameless cop (James Ransone) trying to prevent a new family--a single mom (Shannyn Sossamon) and her twin sons--from falling prey to the home-movie-loving demon Bughuul. Building on what was revealed in
Sinister, the sequel follows one of the boys (Robert Daniel Sloan) as he's guided by Bughuul's ghost children. The new perspective opens up possibilities, but the story feels rehashed, and the snuff films the kid finds are grosser (but not scarier) than the originals. Director Ciaran Foy leans too much on the jump scares, too--a sure sign of lack of confidence.
By
Eric D. Snider