Facts Have No Bias 

Announced bias versus studied impartiality is hardly new; on that, Rasmuson’s right [“A New Hope,” Nov. 14, City Weekly]. However, whichever you pick doesn’t answer the problem you’re trying to address.

For example, I could claim that I was a conservative, and then write a piece that promotes a progressive point of view. Alternatively, I could provide two points of view on a controversy, of which one was far weaker or obviously discredited, and claim that I had provided both sides of the story. Serving either of these—call them academic ideals of journalism—doesn’t solve the problem Rasmuson is implicitly addressing, which is how a journalist goes about informing people.

There are some things that are truly controversial—that is, given all the facts, two equally intelligent and rational people may disagree about an interpretation of the facts. Is a movie a good movie? Is it more important to promote industrial growth than to promote environmental protection? Is it OK to let people die of starvation or illness when they can’t afford food or medical care?

But there are other things that are only controversial to the extent that people disagree about what the facts are. That’s not a true controversy, and yet most journalists do get hung up here on the question Rasmuson is asking, when they decidedly should not.

Now, as I understand it, the gonzo journalism that Hunter S. Thompson promoted or the announced bias that Glenn Greenwald talks about should only affect the first kind of story: true controversies. They should not affect the second kind. Facts should have no bias, and when it turns out that people disagree on facts, journalists aren’t doing their job.

Helge Moulding
Salt Lake City

Pin It
Favorite

More by City Weekly Readers

  • Music to My Ears

    Great articles by Randy Harward on David Lee Roth and Rush ["Hello, Dave," July 16; "Semi-Permanent Waves," July 9, City Weekly]. Please tell me Harward still has the audio clip of David Lee Roth saying "fuck you"—and, pretty please, could he make it available? At least to me?
    • Jul 22, 2015
  • Ban Confederate Flag in Utah

    The Confederate battle flag is a part of our country's history, but it is not to be celebrated. We don't celebrate winning the wars of America's enemies by flying their flags.
    • Jul 15, 2015
  • More »

Latest in Letters

  • Music to My Ears

    Great articles by Randy Harward on David Lee Roth and Rush ["Hello, Dave," July 16; "Semi-Permanent Waves," July 9, City Weekly]. Please tell me Harward still has the audio clip of David Lee Roth saying "fuck you"—and, pretty please, could he make it available? At least to me?
    • Jul 22, 2015
  • Ban Confederate Flag in Utah

    The Confederate battle flag is a part of our country's history, but it is not to be celebrated. We don't celebrate winning the wars of America's enemies by flying their flags.
    • Jul 15, 2015
  • Don't Roll That Way

    We all know how bad the air can get along the Wasatch Front. There are all kinds of suggestions about what to do about it.
    • Jul 8, 2015
  • More »

Comments

Subscribe to this thread:

Add a comment

© 2015 Salt Lake City Weekly

Website powered by Foundation