citylog
The E-
Edition:
CW
page
by page
See Full Calendar
Tumblr.jpg Google_Plus.jpg

 

 

 

 

 

 

 
Music Blog

Missed Masterpieces: Leonard Cohen meets Jeff Buckley

by Lane Heaps
- Posted // 2011-09-06 - This is a story about how two artists who couldn’t be more different from each other came together to make one of the few perfect songs, “Hallelujah.”

I know how subjective this all can be, but anyone who doesn’t think this is a great song, I’ll quickly but politely dismiss.

Leonard Cohen, the songwriter, was born in Montreal in 1934. Despite his reputation as a world-class womanizer, I doubt he has ever done anything that wasn’t on purpose. Cohen has made a lot of great music that will twist your brain into places it’s never been. His music is usually called "folk," but you’ll more typically find him in the "rock & roll" section.

I recommend his Best Of and More Best Of. Stay away from Greatest Hits and Essential, as they only offer a skeleton of the body of his work.

The problem with Leonard Cohen is he didn’t have the vocal chops to make “Hallelujah” the song that it is.

Jeff Buckley, on the other hand, had the vocal chops. He was born in 1966, and died in 1997 in Memphis, rumored to have been drunk and stoned off his ass when he drowned in the Mississippi River.

Buckley, son of folk singer Tim Buckley, only made a couple of albums before he left this life. But one of them, Grace, is an absolute masterpiece that also includes his take on “Hallelujah.”

I think it’s the best cover ever made.


  • Currently 3.5/5 Stars.
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Post a comment
REPLY TO THIS COMMENT
Posted // September 8,2011 at 14:51 As for "Kind of dumb to jump into a river with your clothes and, especially, boots on", while I don't totally disagree that swimming with boots is foolish, Buckley had gone swimming in that same spot a few times before. You had to wear your boots there because of the incredbile amounts of broken glass on the ground. One guy took a pictue of his torn-up boots after walking the bank there. While the Wolfe is typically placid, passing tugboats create a huge amount of suction, ultimately overwhelming Buckley.

 

Posted // September 8,2011 at 15:16 - Your comment only helped cement my opinion. So, there's loads of broken glass on the bank of the Wolfe, prompting a potential swimmer to wear their boots to avoid shredding their feet. AND, it is common for tug boats to cruise the area, creating dangerous currents for potential swimmers. Yet, Buckley swam there, fully clothed, with boots on, knowing tug boats could create dangerous currents. Kind of dumb. I suppose he'd have been fond of swimming tidal rip currents, too. Had somebody other than Buckley done it, the general public would have said, "Well, that's what you get, dummy." His cover of Hallelujah is beautiful, however. There's no denying that.

 

REPLY TO THIS COMMENT
Posted // September 7,2011 at 11:50 1. He made ONE album, not a couple. Demo album released by his mom does not count as an album made by him.
2. He was not drunk or stoned off his ass at all. If you believe rumors rather than the official toxicology report, please visit newstands and get an issue of People magazine.
Unbelievable.

 

Posted // September 7,2011 at 12:07 - Ah, take it easy. I didn't even know the dude was dead. Kind of dumb to jump into a river with your clothes and, especially, boots on. Stupidity killed Buckley - these are the kinds of things people are given the Darwin Award for. If it were me, I'd rather it have been drugs and booze. At least I'd have an excuse. And a buzz.

 

REPLY TO THIS COMMENT
Posted // September 7,2011 at 09:49 The toxicology report ruled out illegal substances, and indicated he was sober when he went into the Wolf River that day. Poor choice of words, in an otherwise flattering commentary.

 

REPLY TO THIS COMMENT
Posted // September 7,2011 at 03:22 Truly a beautiful combination.

 

 
 
Close
Close
Close