The E-
by page

Tumblr.jpg Google_Plus.jpg







Movies Blog

R.I.P. Roger Ebert

by Scott Renshaw
- Posted // 2013-04-04 - In January 1999, I sat down to dinner at a Park City restaurant with the man who helped make film criticism accessible for a generation -- and helped make it possible for me to do what I do.

It was thanks to the Internet-based film critic James Berardinelli -- whom Ebert had been corresponding with for a while -- that I got that chance for a dinner with Roger Ebert at Sundance '99. Ebert had been an early adapter to the significance of the online world, and had made it a point in his annual Movie Yearbook beginning in the late 1990s to single out the Internet-based film critics he considered worthwhile. Mr. Berardinelli was one of those -- and, in Mr. Ebert's opinion circa 1998, so was I.

I was fairly dumbfounded when an online acquaintance made me aware that I'd made the cut in Ebert's Yearbook. After all, I'd been watching since his PBS Sneak Previews show with Gene Siskel in the early 1980s; he was a Pulitzer Prize-winner at a craft I'd barely begun to feel competent at; he was The Man. A thumbs-up from Roger Ebert was the most astonishing indication I'd yet received that maybe there was a shot for me at this crazy film-criticism thing. And I don't think it hurt my bona fides when I walked into the City Weekly offices in spring 1999 and showed Publisher John Saltas a copy of those words of praise from Roger Ebert.

So in January of 1999, I was able to thank Roger Ebert in person for that kindness. I wish I could remember more of that dinner conversation; I think I was too awestruck for it to feel casual. I do remember his casual jests about Gene Siskel, who would pass away himself only a couple of months later. And I remember that he picked up the check.

In subsequent years, I'd see him periodically, and while there's no way of knowing whether he'd have remembered my name without those ever-present press badges, he always greeted me and was willing to chat. That seems to be the memory of so many people today: That someone who had reached the top of his profession, instead of becoming a standoffish jerk, was instead kind and inviting.

Rest in peace in the greatest balcony seat, Mr. Ebert. And thanks again.

  • Currently 3.5/5 Stars.
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Post a comment
Posted // April 5,2013 at 11:39

Oddly enough, Ebert influenced my criticism as well. He happened to sit down next to me years ago at a Sundance screening. Before the film began, a half-dozen people came up to him and asked him what he thought of this movie or that movie. He politely declined to discuss them, saying "I don't like to talk about the films I review until I've written about them. " 

I take the same approach to restaurant criticism. I won't pick apart a meal or disect it until it has been well "digested," literally and figuratively. I thank Roger Ebert for teaching me that lesson in patient criticism.  


Posted // April 5,2013 at 09:58

I certainly do remember that you had the Ebert bona fide thumbs up, Scott. Thanks for this tribute and thanks for rattling my grey matter. Ebert was a writer first, a notion I discovered too late.


Posted // April 4,2013 at 19:58

It was always nice to see him at Sundance over the years. He was an early champion of the festival, since the mid-eighties, I believe. I chatted with him one night at the 1990 festival, and he was a gem. RIP, Roger.