The E-
by page

Tumblr.jpg Google_Plus.jpg







News Blog

Petitions Call for End to Horse-Drawn Carriages in SLC

by Eric S. Peterson
- Posted // 2013-08-19 -

Saturday, a 13-year-old horse named “Jerry” collapsed in Salt Lake City while carrying passengers by carriage around downtown Salt Lake City on a day when the temperature hit a high of 98 degrees. Now, multiple petitions are calling on the Salt Lake City Council to end horse-drawn-carriage rides in Salt Lake City.

One online petition has already gathered more than 1,200 signatures seeking an end to carriage rides that regularly take tourists and others around Temple Square and downtown Salt Lake City. The petition organizer, Donna Pemmitt, noted that after Jerry's collapse on the afternoon of Saturday, Aug. 17, he had to be dragged with ropes onto a trailer and hauled by a forklift into a barn.

“It's time for Salt Lake City to do away with this cruel industry,” the petition reads. “Please contact the Salt Lake City Council and politely tell them to end this cruelty!”

The Salt Lake Tribune reported that the horse's owners say that he was also suffering from colic, which may have led to his collapse. Still, many are questioning the safety of horses carrying passengers during sweltering heat amidst downtown traffic, including Councilman Charlie Luke, who asked the question on Facebook Saturday: “Are congested downtown streets really appropriate settings for horses?”

It's a point also raised by animal-rights activist Amy Meyer, who is also hosting an online petition that, when signed by Utah residents, automatically e-mails the Salt Lake City Council and Salt Lake City Mayor's Office.

"These dangerous conditions are inherent to the use of horse-drawn carriages in an urban environment," Meyer's petition reads. "They cannot be corrected with regulation because it’s impossible to reshape the landscape of our city to suit horses."

If you have an opinion on this, you can sign Pemmitt's petition here and/or Meyer's petition. You can also find your council representative's contact info here, or you can submit general comments to

*Photo courtesy Jeremy Beckham, via Reddit

  • Currently 3.5/5 Stars.
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Post a comment
Posted // August 21,2013 at 13:00

Horses are not mean to spend their days and half the night on cement streets, working so these men can make a living.   Please stop Horse & Carriage, this is not right for our horses, they need a green pasture to be in and spring water.



Posted // August 21,2013 at 08:42

This  should be a felony. . .


Posted // August 20,2013 at 10:36

this must stop NOW.  we don't need horses in the streets of any city and most people don't want it.  it is cruel & unnecessary and only for profit & greed, drivers, get a real job.


Posted // August 20,2013 at 12:44 - I want to see Jerry. I want to know hat happened and his prognosis. I think we need to see him NOW!!!


Posted // August 20,2013 at 10:10

Let those burly men pull the carriages in the heat for a week, and see how they feel. They will be crying like little girls !!


Posted // August 19,2013 at 18:01

13 Is young for a horse,Melissa. Most live well into their 20-30. If they didn't realize he was colicing,it's even more horrifying,due to the painful and often fatal nature of the illness. The reason they were whipping him is once they go down like that you MUST get them up,if they begin rolling they will twist their intestines. It sucks,but they were trying to avoid dragging him. . . I think it's awful to have animals treated this way and something needs to happen,now!