Banker’s Heart 

Pin It
Favorite

When a political fight gets truly ugly, it’s a pretty good bet that the stuff below the surface is what is really driving the debate. The stormy, 20-year fight between Utah banks and credit unions has gotten to that stage. They say it is in part about market share. They say it’s also about competitive fairness. But what it’s really about is ideology.


Banks want credit unions to be more like banks. They want credit unions to declare profits, then pay taxes on those profits. In short, banks would rather credit unions were not what they are: democratic, member-run institutions that operate on a non-profit basis and hold funds in reserve to ensure their stability for the long-term benefit of their members.


This, the banks say, sounds like Marxism.


Hyperbole? Here’s what the Utah Banker’s Association says on its website: “Profit is what drives the free market. We can draw attention to the fact that credit union activists eventually come off sounding like Marxists.” http://www.uba.org/credit_unions/editor.html.


If that’s true, isn’t it interesting that even Grover Norquist, president of Americans for Tax Reform and a key adviser to President Bush, has come down on the side of the pesky “socialists” in opposing House Bill 162, sponsored by Rep. Jeff Alexander (R-Provo), which would impose new taxes on credit unions.


The latest version of the bill delays implementation of the 30 percent tax on so-called “retained earnings” until a legislative commission can study the matter. It retains a new 5 percent corporate franchise tax. House Speaker Marty Stephens, a vice president at Zions Bank, has declared he will steer clear of the debate, but let’s be real. He’s the Speaker. We all know where he stands. Anyone wanting to curry favor is going to vote with him on this one. Also on the side of the banks is another impartial expert, former Sen. Jake Garn, co-author of the Garn-St. Germain Act in 1982, which deregulated the S&L industry.


Credit unions are popular in Utah because they still care about their customers. What bankers are trying to do is fix with law what their own policies have belied for years. Heard the expression “cold as a banker’s heart”? Banks forfeited consumer trust a long time ago when they started jacking up one fee after another and imposing restrictions on how you can use your own money.


When I moved to Utah a few months ago, I went from bank to bank looking for the best deal to open a checking account. One bank, Wells Fargo, told me its policy on deposits was to hold them for four days, even if I was depositing cash. Cash. My cash.


Banks want credit unions not to be credit unions anymore. They want them to be banks, because they can’t stand the idea of competing with a cooperative. Cooperatives are evil. They are Marxist. They are, therefore, un-American.


I wonder. In a recent poll by that quasi-pinko newspaper, the Deseret News, 57 percent of Utahns oppose additional taxes on their credit unions.


Perhaps we’re going about this backwards—which is not surprising from this nutty bunch at the Legislature. Perhaps we should be trying to make banks more like credit unions. That would be the Utah thing to do.

Pin It
Favorite

About The Author

John Yewell

More by John Yewell

  • Yewell’s Log

    Yewell’s Quarter Column On Virtuous Politicians, Poor News Judgment and Credibility Called Into Question
    • Jun 11, 2007
  • Move a Few Chairs

    I didn’t mean to do it. I must have tried that one on my parents a hundred times. Didn’t work then, doesn’t even work now—and when it comes to public officials, it should never work. Salt Lake County Council members Joe Hatch...
    • Jun 11, 2007
  • The Big Chill

    It may come as a surprise to those cynical about the newspaper business to learn that we who buy ink by the barrel have no interest in stories that are later proven to be full of holes—or cut from whole cloth. Credibility, like virginity, is hard...
    • Jun 11, 2007
  • More »

Latest in News

  • The Life Outside

    Six months after delivering watershed speech, Spencer Cox reflects on equal rights, family and virality.
    • Dec 7, 2016
  • Silent Survivors

    A women-only shelter might be insufficient to address needs of sex workers and the crime that often accompanies them.
    • Nov 30, 2016
  • Gauging HB 348

    Some consider penalty reduction bill a silver bullet for much-needed prison reform.
    • Nov 23, 2016
  • More »

Comments

Subscribe to this thread:

Add a comment

Readers also liked…

  • Wild and Dead

    Cause of burro deaths a mystery for BLM.
    • Jun 22, 2016
  • Bank On It

    Thanks to luck and a loophole, Utah is an unlikely hub for the nation's industrial banks
    • Apr 22, 2015

© 2016 Salt Lake City Weekly

Website powered by Foundation