The E-
by page

Tumblr.jpg Google_Plus.jpg







Home / Articles / Movies & TV / Film Reviews /  Another Earth
Film Reviews

Another Earth

A hilarious mess of sci-fi drama

By Scott Renshaw
Photo by Fox Searchlight // Another Earth
Posted // August 12,2011 -

The concept behind the Sundance 2011 entry Another Earth is that astronomers have discovered a planet that may be an exact duplicate of our Earth, including identical versions of every human on it. Yes, it’s a huge celestial metaphor for our desire for second chances—and that’s actually the most plausible thing in this unintentionally hilarious mess of a sci-fi drama.

On the night that the discovery of the planet is announced, 17-year-old Rhoda (co-screenwriter Brit Marling) is responsible for a car crash—effectively, jarringly staged—that takes the life of the wife and child of composer John Burroughs (William Mapother). Four years later—after Rhoda has been released from prison—she makes contact with John, who has no idea of her role in the tragic events that changed his life. Meanwhile, a contest is offering a chance for someone to take the first trip to Earth 2—and guess who wants to go.

Marling and co-scripter/director Mike Cahill at least make an effort to explain why Rhoda should take such actions; it’s a familiar “trying to wash away the guilt” arc, but at least it makes sense at the outset. Nothing else that these characters do or say, however, feels remotely like the behavior of actual humans.

Do I believe that John has been sitting around a disintegrating house for four years in a toque and a stained T-shirt getting drunk? Do I believe that even after calling the cleaning agency Rhoda claims to be working for in order to get inside his house, John still lets her in? Do I believe that the scene in which John plays a saw—let me repeat that: a saw—for Rhoda is really supposed to inspire a sense of impending romance, rather than uncontrollable giggles? Or maybe this is all meant for some alternate Earth, where goofiness like this can be taken seriously.

Brit Marling, William Mapother

Twitter: @ScottRenshaw

  • Currently 3.5/5 Stars.
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Post a comment
Posted // August 12,2011 at 09:47 I LOVED the musical saw scene! It was a pivotal point in the movie - it was the first moment where you start to see John come out of his shell. And the music was gorgeous! The musical saw sounds part human part celectial. I downloaded it from iTunes (search Natalia Paruz)


Posted // August 12,2011 at 08:47 The saw scene:
The LA Times, Boston Globe, Wall Street Journal, and MSN Movies all had incredibly high praise for the musical saw scene and the musical saw music in the film which I wrote and can be found on my website: Google Scott Munson Music.
It was performed on the soundtrack by Natalia 'Saw Lady' Paruz.


Posted // August 11,2011 at 20:22 So is this saw scene hillariously-bad enough to rank up with The Room?