citylog
The E-
Edition:
CW
page
by page

Tumblr.jpg Google_Plus.jpg

 

 

 

 

 

 

 
Home / Articles / News / Letters /  Regulate the Mexican!
Letters

Regulate the Mexican!

By City Weekly Readers
Posted // April 8,2009 -

I strongly disagree with the Ask a Mexican feature by Gustavo Arellano. In our day and age, we should be trying to move past the stereotypes that this column incorporates in the questions on some weeks. How can Utahns attempt to rise above racial differences if columns like these continue to drive cultures apart? There should be stronger regulations addressing which questions get published.

Some weeks, the questions are idiotic and stereotypical, and make non-Mexicans look as though they are clueless about anything outside their own culture.

February 19th’s question was something I could not believe came out of someone’s mouth. It was about how Mexican families confront the issue of child sexual abuse.

The questioner asked why pedophiles don’t just “focus on Mexican children, since with them is the least chance that their parents will acknowledge the problem.”

Most weeks, the questions are derogatory toward Mexicans. Those which do not contain derogatory questions are beneficial for readers hoping to gain perspective on the Mexican way of life. I encourage the questions about definitions of words and their context.

If this column could help other cultures recognize the differences between Mexican traditions and their own, it would be a positive thing for the Valley. In attempting to make this column a constructive one, you could first change the name. The column could then begin to include other cultures that are dominant in this area. The Mexican race is not the only group people have questions about. This column is supposed to raise awareness, but we should be trying to raise awareness for all different cultures, not just specifically Mexicans.

Kristen Sproul
Salt Lake City

Editor’s note: Ask a Mexican is a nationally syndicated column. Author Gustavo Arellano’s stated purpose with his column is to humorously confront stereotypes.

 
  • Currently 3.5/5 Stars.
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Post a comment
REPLY TO THIS COMMENT
Posted // April 8,2009 at 15:49

I think that many readers, including Kristen Sproul, recognize that "Ask a Mexican" is intended to be satirical. Does that make it any less offensive? No.

I'm not sure that a place as culturally homogeneous as Utah is sophisticated enough for this type of so-called humor. And as a Mexican who is told frequently that I don't "look Mexican" by caucasian Utahns, I feel pretty justified in saying that we can and should do without further stereotyping. Please reconsider this column in favor of content that is worthy of your paper.

- A. Parker

 

 
 
Close
Close
Close