citylog
The E-
Edition:
CW
page
by page

PROUDLY SUPPORTS
Buy Local FirstHumane SocietyPlanned Parenthood
SLC Arts CouncilDowntown Alliance

 

 

 

 

 

 

 
Home / Articles / Food / Restaurant Reviews /  Two Barbecue Joints
Restaurant Reviews

Two Barbecue Joints

One good, one not so good

By Ted Scheffler
Posted // September 5,2011 -

I always try to be a little cautious when throwing the term “barbecue” around, since it means very different things to different people. To most Americans, I suspect, barbecue is synonymous with all outdoor cooking and grilling. As in, “Come on over to our place for a barbecue!” But to hardcore barbecue aficionados like those who compete in, for example, cooking competitions sanctioned by the Kansas City Barbecue Society—of which I am a trained and certified judge—the word barbecue refers to slow (low heat) pit cooking. It’s much more than merely a matter of throwing a few burgers or some shrimp on the barbie; it’s hours and hours of methodical cooking, rubs, mops and more. So, today we turn our attention to two relatively new barbecue joints: one that is of the Kansas City Barbecue Society would approve of, the other distinctly not.

First up: Terrapin Station Smokin’ Co., which is a traditional, low-and-slow barbecue eatery that began as a catering outfit and recently opened as a sit-down restaurant. A friend warned me a few months ago that Terrapin Station was not without glitches, and he was correct. Unfortunately, it’s still not without glitches. In fact, there are aspects of this restaurant that are just downright odd.

Walking into the place—which looks like a ‘70s throwback nostalgia restaurant, full of macramé and hanging plants—we weren’t quite sure what to do. It was a Friday night, but the restaurant was nearly empty, and there was no one to greet or seat us. Eventually, a woman—who would turn out to be our “server”—emerged from the back. We were given menus and instructed to find a seat and return to the front counter when we were ready to order, which we did. We paid for our dinner in advance, which I thought was odd. What if we wanted dessert or something else later? I guess we’d just start all over again. Anyway, with food orders in place, we sat down again, and I realized I’d forgotten to ask for one of the available microbrews. But, our server had again vanished. In short, this is what passes for service at Terrapin Station.

If the food were better, the sloppy service would be more tolerable. But, as much as I want to love this barbecue operation, I just don’t. For starters, the side dishes we sampled were mediocre at best. I mean, how in the world could anyone screw up something as basic as cornbread? “Creole cornbread” was dry and virtually without flavor. French fries were lukewarm and limp. Barbecued beans were mushy, yet dry, although with a nice, spicy kick. Again, I could probably overlook all that if the meats were mind-blowing, but they weren’t.

Advertised as “World-Class Southern-Style Barbecue,” there wasn’t anything world-class about my barbecue sampler plate ($20 with cornbread and two sides). The beef brisket was tender, but not particularly flavorful, and the pulled pork was one of the weaker versions I’ve ever tried. A quarter-rack of ribs was tough and chewy, and a dried-out chicken thigh had seen better days. Oddly, some of the sauces are very good, including the Helldorado and honey-chipotle sauces. Terrapin Station sells their bottled sauces and rubs, which I recommend purchasing and applying to your own homemade barbecue.

By contrast, I loved almost everything at Layton’s Big Sai’s Hawaiian Bar-B-Q except the size. The new eatery is a hole-in-the-wall with a walk-up-and-order counter, five tables and a couple of window seats—seating for 22 people, total. It’s always crowded at lunchtime and for early dinners when the folks at nearby Hill AFB get off work. But, you can always get your Hawaiian-style barbecue to take home.

One wall of Big Sai’s is an homage to Hawaiian football players, with signed and autographed jerseys and photos from the likes of Troy Polamalu, Lofa Tatupu, Junior Ioane and many more. On the opposite wall is a simple painting of the Hawaiian Islands, with only the town of Laie on Oahu highlighted—where the family that operates Big Sai’s comes from. As for Big Sai? Well, he ain’t so big. He’s actually the 9-year-old son of the owners.

Big Sai’s is a small place with big flavors, not to mention big portions for little prices. Menu items include teriyaki beef and chicken, Kalua pork, fried spam & eggs, Laie chicken wings and Japanese-style chicken katsu. Most of the menu items come in a “mini” size ($4.50-$6.50) or “regular” ($5.95-$8.95) and include a side of rice and macaroni salad.

There is nothing mini about the mini portions. The mixed mini plate ($6.50) consists of one grilled short rib; four or five boneless, grilled chicken thigh pieces; and about a quarter-pound of beef, along with a mound of white rice and a hefty portion of macaroni salad, all topped with a slightly sweet teriyaki sauce, mildly spiked with garlic. Both the chicken and beef were very tender, the beef especially. And, I’ve gotta tell you, the macaroni salad here is bodacious. I took an order home and was so impressed that I called back to find out how the macaroni salad was made. Turns out it’s nothing more than al dente macaroni, a little mayonnaise, shredded carrot and black pepper. That’s it. I could have sworn there was some sort of mild cheese in it. It tasted like mild mac & cheese, not mac & mayo.

Another great choice is Loco Moco ($4.50), which is two grilled beef patties topped with two fried eggs, smothered in brown gravy. I could feel my arteries hardening as I ate it and loved every bite, but I still couldn’t resist ordering the guava cake. As Sai’s T-shirts say, this food “broke da mouf.”?

TERRAPIN STATION SMOKIN' CO.
2020 E. 3300 South, Salt Lake City
801-466-9246
TerrapinStationSmokinCo.com

BIG SAI'S HAWAIIAN BAR-B-Q
2672 N. Hillfield Road, Layton
801-774-7247

 
  • Currently 3.5/5 Stars.
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Post a comment
REPLY TO THIS COMMENT
Posted // September 30,2011 at 09:50 Any of the other reviewers that give glowing remarks to the menu items should be promptly ignored, as they are most likely just pawns shilling for the owner.
That said, the pulled pork is probably Terrapin Station's best item. But it's quite unremarkable in its own right. However, the Water of Life sauce is pretty tasty. Other than that, everything else on the menu is bland and dry. I mean, how do you screw up cornbread? You get better, moister cornbread out of a box.
If you want to spend a lot of your hard-earned money on sub-par food, I'd say stop in today. You'll hate the "service," which is pretty much nonexistent. And you won't be able to get a beer with your meal. Good times!
In short, I'd go to Pat's. Great food. Good service. Beer.
-Johnny

 

REPLY TO THIS COMMENT
Posted // September 23,2011 at 08:48 My experience at Terrapin Station is totally different than Mr. Scheffler's. The meat I have had has been tender, smokey to perfection, and delicious. I am particcularly fond of the pulled chicken sandwich with a little wing sauce. I think their french fries are just about the best I've ever had - crispy and cooked to perfection, and made from real potatoes in the restaurant. Maybe the reviewer had a bad visit but don't let it stop you from trying it out. Oh yeah - the service? Friendly! I don't see anything wrong about going back to the counter to order more food or desert - just like other barbecue joints (like Pat's). One morel thing, no beer permit yet so ignore that part of the review. They also have live music a night or two every week. Live, good music. Bon appetite.

 

REPLY TO THIS COMMENT
Posted // September 18,2011 at 10:03 I'd like to start off by saying that I know the owner of Terrapin Station and in turn I know a lot about the food they offer. First off, he does not have a Helldorado sauce. There is a Helldorado rub for fries or ribs (and nuts and jerky), but if you were thinking of a hot sauce it would either be Holy Hell or Water of Life. Second off, he does not have a honey-chipotle sauce, nor has he obtained a liquor license so microbrews wouldn't even be available.
With that out of the way, I do want to invite you to come try it again. I'm assuming you tried the restaurant earlier in the year, towards when it first opened. A lot has changed since then and through constructive criticism Terrapin Station has made a lot of improvements (especially on the service!). I just simply want to make a point that one visit shouldn't shape your whole opinion of a place.

 

REPLY TO THIS COMMENT
Posted // September 5,2011 at 10:55 While I agree with the criticism regarding the service at Terrapin Station, I think the food is actually some of the best BBQ in SLC. Their sauces are amazing! I do hope TS reconsiders how they provide service for the customers.

 

 
 
 
Close
Close
Close