The Long and the Short of It: Extending Shane Acker’s bleak animated 9 improves its action, but not its story.

Pin It
click to enlarge art9073widea.jpg

Once upon a time, if you saw a short film, you saw the work of someone who wanted to make a short film. Nowadays, that ain’t necessarily so.

In 2006, Shane Acker’s 10-minute computer-animated 9 was nominated for a Best Animated Short Oscar—but by that point, Tim Burton was already working with Acker to develop it into a feature. It became the latest in a line of “calling card” shorts: works created by inexperienced filmmakers hoping to get a full-length movie out of their efforts. In just such a way, Jared Hess’s short Peluca became Napoleon Dynamite; Ryan Fleck and Anna Boden’s Gowanus, Brooklyn became Half Nelson. Sometimes, the raw material was there for something bigger and richer.

Sometimes, it’s not. In its expanded form, 9 remains a dazzlingly innovative vision that showcases Acker’s skill as a director. But in trying to develop the mythology behind his story, Acker loses sight of its appealing mystery.

The title refers to the number scrawled on the back of a rag doll (Elijah Wood) who awakes with no knowledge of the world. Wandering through a crumbling, corpse-strewn city, he soon spots a similar figure marked as 2 (Martin Landau), and learns that a dangerous, mechanized predator stalks the streets. But how did these sewn-together bits of burlap achieve sentience? What happened to all the humans? What is the significance of a strange, dome-shaped artifact 9 carries from the place of his birth?

The short film version of 9 notably answered none of those questions. The numbered protagonists never spoke, and the question of humanity’s fate never entered into things. Here, we discover that a human scientist perfected an artificial brain known as The Machine that eventually came to be used for fascistic military purposes—before The Machine built its own army and wiped out civilization. As a result, the post-apocalyptic landscape the characters occupy feels considerably more mundane—a Terminator universe with John Connor turned into a puppet.

And that’s a shame, because Acker clearly has filmmaking chops when he’s dealing with purely visual storytelling. His world is full of fascinating visual conceits, including the way The Machine turns its minions into hybrids of pre-historical creatures— like saber-tooth tigers or pteranodons—and robots, or one of the electronic dolls using a magnet as a consciousness-altering drug of choice. Breathtaking choreography marks every one of his action sequences, the editing and tension-building choices demonstrating the kind of precision that should make every slavering Michael Bay fanboy embarrassed to consider Transformers a piece of cinema. The short 9 suggested the kind of potential Acker could have as a feature filmmaker. Amazingly, this version of 9 makes it look like we underestimated him.

It’s just a shame that he’s not working with script elements as compelling as the visual backdrop. Pamela Pettler (Tim Burton’s Corpse Bride collaborator) developed the screenplay from Acker’s story ideas, and they’re trying to express some themes about responding to crisis—the isolationist, self-preservation mode favored by the dolls’ self-appointed leader 1 (Christopher Plummer) versus 9’s preference for facing the threat head-on. But 9 does little to develop these characters beyond their opposing philosophies, and limp vocal performances by Wood and Jennifer Connelly (as the doll with the strongest warrior mentality) do little to add personality. When you’ve cast Crispin Glover as one of your voices and even he seems to disappear into the scenery, something’s seriously amiss.

Because 9 is an animated feature, it’s inevitable that some potential viewers are going to assume it’s kid-friendly, which it most decidedly is not. Even more so than Coraline, it’s a dark vision more likely to inspire nightmares than delight. In fact, 9 has much more in common with summertime action eye-candy than with family entertainment; it’s an astonishing technical achievement that never quite pulls together a gripping narrative. There’s reason enough to watch 9 just to thrill to Acker’s brilliant filmmaking chops and anticipate what he could be capable of once he latches on to a great story. While he spent a lot of time on expanding the context of his short, I’m waiting to see what happens when he learns his own lessons: It’s one thing to bring something to life, but you’ve also got to give it soul.


click to enlarge 3_stars.gif

Voices of Elijah Wood, John C. Reilly, Jennifer Connelly
Rated PG-13

Try These

click to enlarge cinema_try_these_090910_a.jpg
Spike & Mike’s Sick & Twisted Festival of Animation — Unprotected!
Not Rated
click to enlarge cinema_trythese_090910_b.jpg
Corpse Bride
Johnny Depp
Helena Bonham Carter
Rated PG
click to enlarge cinema_try_these_090910_c.jpg
Half Nelson
Ryan Gosling
Shareeka Epps
Rated R
click to enlarge cinema_try_these_090910_d.jpg
Dakota Fanning
Teri Hatcher
Rated PG

Pin It

Speaking of...

  • It's Kind of a Funny Story

    Sad Clown: A comedian shows his dramatic skills in It’s Kind of a Funny Story.
    • Oct 8, 2010
  • Robin Hood

    We Wuz Robbed: Ridley Scott’s Robin Hood can’t deliver promise of a story behind the legend.
    • May 12, 2010
  • Iron Man 2

    Stark Contrast: Iron Man 2 leaves you wanting more of the guy who made the original fly.
    • May 6, 2010
  • More »

More by Scott Renshaw

Latest in Film Reviews

  • Fall Flicks

    Our picks for the "awards season" movies most worth getting excited about.
    • Oct 19, 2016
  • Making a Statement

    American Honey offers a terrific slice of life, whenever it's not trying too hard.
    • Oct 12, 2016
  • New Eyes

    The story behind the story inevitably changes how you see The Birth of a Nation.
    • Oct 5, 2016
  • More »


Subscribe to this thread:

Add a comment

Readers also liked…

  • Where Are the Women?

    A critic's year-long deep-dive into the way movies portray one half of humanity.
    • May 11, 2016
  • Beasts of One Notion

    Zootopia depends entirely on its well-intentioned allegory about prejudice.
    • Mar 2, 2016

© 2016 Salt Lake City Weekly

Website powered by Foundation